Eating The Sour Elephant
You awake alone on a desert island surrounded by endless ocean. A single palm tree provides shade next to a barrel of fresh water.
Originally published on the rexstjohn.com blog

Originally published at rexstjohn.com on March 27, 2014. Recovered from the Internet Archive.

You awake alone on a desert island surrounded by endless ocean. A single palm tree provides shade next to a barrel of fresh water.
Alarmed at your sudden change in circumstances, you find that your left hand clutches a small knife and fork and in your right there is a note which reads:
“Before you can leave the island, you must eat the sour elephant. All of it.”
Upon reading these words, a massive purple elephant carcass appears flopped across the far end of your island. Judging from the fêted smell issuing from the carcass, it is indeed quite sour.
Astonished and perplexed you react with denial: “I don’t deserve this. I am not eating this stupid elephant carcass, it smells terrible.”
Your creative brain leaps into action. Dozens of excuses and shortcuts present themselves. You spend weeks trying them out: “Maybe if I carve off chunks of the elephant and throw them in the ocean, sharks will do the eating for me….”
No sooner have you carved off a chunk and thrown it into the ocean, the missing parts magically reappear. Your attempts to interest passing seagulls in feasting on the elephant are unsuccessful. Despondent and out of ideas, you spend three days shivering through the night weeping and cursing your situation.
On the fourth day, you finally find the courage to take one bite. “Maybe it doesn’t taste as bad as it smells,” you think. With your tiny knife and fork you saw off a small piece and start chewing. It tastes like Green Apple Skittles mixed with NyQuil.
After forcing down a single swallow of sour purple elephant you fall into deep emotional despair.”I can’t do this, my barrel of water is running out by the day….I am going to die out here.”
Sizing up the palm tree you wonder if maybe you can’t fashion some sort of premature death for yourself. Maybe if you jump off at the right angle you can break your neck. You disregard that strategy because you want to keep living.
Having exhausted all of your excuses and set aside the possibility of quitting, the real work begins: You commit to eating ten bites of giant sour purple elephant a day, taking ample rest between each bite to avoid illness. After three weeks of this, ten bites per day no longer seems so bad.
Now that you have set aside all possible excuses, solutions begin to present themselves: Rubbing sand on your tongue and gargling ocean water seems to act as a palette cleanser. Adopting this new method allows you to increase from ten to fifteen bites of sour elephant a day.
As the weeks roll by, you are also given ample time to improve your personal philosophy.
You think about what you do for work and how the things you produce help people. By not eating this elephant, you would be letting down your friends and family as well as the rest of humanity.
Your thinking now begins to take on an almost religious quality: Eating the elephant has gone from a chore to a duty you owe to the rest of the universe. The importance of your struggles as an individual gradually diminish.
As you slowly eat away at the elephant, you start seeing your task in new ways. “Maybe this elephant is actually not as large as it looks. Maybe I have just been exaggerating the difficulty. I should be lucky the elephant is only sour, maybe someone else on another island got an elephant that tastes like paint thinner. Maybe I should wake up every day and thank the gods my elephant tastes of Green Apple Skittles and NyQuil.”
After six months, the sour elephant has been reduced to a single remaining toe. As you pop this last delicious morsel into your mouth (you long ago decided to regard the elephant as a sort of rare delicacy which only you have the privilege to dine upon), you reflect on the journey you have made in your own mind.
“If I can eat a gigantic sour elephant and convince myself it tastes delicious, what else can I do?”
Seeing that you have completed your allotted task, the universe wraps itself around you and whisks you away to your next destination.
Now Do It Again
You awake on a larger island (with an even larger sour purple elephant) with two other people, all clutching a note which says “The sour elephant must be eaten, all of it.” The note says nothing about who needs to eat the elephant, just that it all must be eaten.
The first person panics and attempts to chop down the palm tree with a rock in order to build a poorly considered raft. The second buries their head into the sand and weeps uncontrollably for days at a time.
Your attempts to talk the other two survivors into helping to eat the new sour elephant largely fail: They always seem to have excuses. When the work becomes difficult, the other two can always be found swimming or hiding in purpose-built sand castles. Attempting to reason with them has no effect. After taking a half-hearted bite or two of the elephant, they always quit and resort to playing Tic-Tac-Toe in the sand. You do your best to ignore them and attempt to maintain your daily quota of 20 bites of sour elephant. They frequently try to talk you out of doing so or distract you with their antics.
Falling asleep every night you find yourself increasingly upset with the rest of your “team.” Don’t they understand that they all need to be helping? Don’t they realize that quitting and making excuses is not an option? Don’t they realize that none of us are getting off this island until this elephant has been completely eaten?
The hairs around your temple grow white as you repeatedly attempt to make the situation clear to them: “I have been on an island like this before and I got off by eating the elephant just like the note said.”
Unimpressed, the others argue with you: “Who is to say that if we eat THIS elephant we won’t wind up on yet another island? Stop being so**excitable, we have plenty of rain water. Maybe if we light the palm tree on fire we will attract the attention of a ship. If we wait around long enough an airplane will probably fly over.”
The constant friction causes you to question your philosophies which you had learned before. “Maybe I do not have a higher purpose. Maybe I should just quit. Why am I working so hard to help these two get off this island.”
With each passing day, you find yourself less and less willing to “Chip In” for the greater good. You find yourself playing an occasional game of Tic-Tac-Toe in the sand with the others and swimming more frequently. Eventually you learn to sort of ignore the 75% eaten sour elephant and relax.
After all, who knows, maybe a ship will appear one day on the horizon and you can skip the hard part entirely.