Skip to content
Rex St. John

Get in touch

Eating The Sour Elephant: Chapter 2

You awake on a large island along with two strangers, each clutching a note which says “All of the sour elephant must be eaten if you want to leave the island.”

Originally published on the rexstjohn.com blog

Originally published at rexstjohn.com on March 28, 2014. Recovered from the Internet Archive.

You awake on a large island along with two strangers, each clutching a note which says “All of the sour elephant must be eaten if you want to leave the island.”

The note says nothing about who needs to eat the elephant, just that all of it must be eaten. The instant that you have read this note, a massive purple elephant carcass materializes before your eyes.

The first stranger panics and attempts to batter down the island’s only palm tree with a blunt rock in order to build a poorly considered raft. The second buries their head into the sand and weeps uncontrollably for days at a time.

Having been in this situation before and eaten your way out of the problem, you cooly inform the two strangers that there is only one way to escape: “We must do what the note advises and eat the elephant, even if it sucks.”

After you explain this several times, the strangers nod and agree with you cordially. “Yes…the fact that no one has eaten the sour elephant is definitely a concern. Something will have to be done about it…”

At first you leave these discussions feeling positive that you got the message across. It isn’t until several weeks have gone by that you realize that your companions are just telling you what they think you want to hear in order to end the discussion faster. They have no actual intention of putting in any real work towards solving the challenge.

Growing impatient, you eventually convince them to help you at least try to eat the elephant. After taking a half-hearted bite or two, the two strangers quit and resort to playing Tic-Tac-Toe in the sand, hiding in purpose built sandcastles and swimming. One of them even manages to fashion a sort of primitive “putting green” out of a piece of driftwood and a coconut and spends hours perfecting their swing.

“Who put you in charge? How do we know you aren’t lying about your past experience. The elephant tastes disgusting, we don’t want to eat it…”

Throwing up your arms in disgust you resolve to take the duty on entirely yourself.

You begin a tight schedule of eating 20 bites of sour elephant per day and manage to maintain this rate of activity for several months. Noting your serious attitude, the strangers write you off as being an irascible social troll and pass the time by skipping stones and sleeping in the shade of the purple elephant carcass. 

Falling asleep every night, you find yourself increasingly upset with the rest of your “team.” Don’t they understand that they all need to be helping? Don’t they realize that quitting and making excuses is not an option? Don’t they realize that none of us are getting off this island until this elephant has been completely eaten?

The hairs around your temple grow white as you repeatedly attempt to make the situation clear to them: “I have been on an island like this before and I got off by eating the elephant just like the note said.”

Unimpressed, the others argue with you constantly: “Who is to say that if we eat THIS elephant we won’t wind up on yet another island? Stop being so**excitable, we have plenty of rain water. Maybe if we light the palm tree on fire we will attract the attention of a ship. If we wait around long enough an airplane will probably fly over. If we eat the elephant, we won’t have enough shade to sleep in.”

After several meetings and lengthy discussions, the two strangers agree that your attitude is definitely the problem. 

With each passing day, you find yourself less and less willing to “Chip In” for the greater good. You find yourself playing an occasional game of Tic-Tac-Toe in the sand with the others and swimming more frequently. Your skill at coconut-driftwood putting grows to formidable levels. Eventually you learn to sort of ignore the 75% eaten sour elephant and relax.

*“Who knows, maybe a ship will appear one day on the horizon and you can skip the hard part entirely…Maybe I am being irrational. Maybe this isn’t such a big deal after all.”*You begin to mutter to yourself.

Decades later, still trapped on the island, you are all drowned by a typhoon.