How reliable is "that" Henry Ford quote?
The first automobile was a motorized tricycle built a decade before Henry Ford took interest Everyone has heard this Henry Ford quote: “If I had asked...
Originally published at rexstjohn.com on June 27, 2015. Recovered from the Internet Archive.
The first automobile was a motorized tricycle built a decade before Henry Ford took interest
Everyone has heard this Henry Ford quote: “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” We see it plastered on Twitter and LinkedIn (often supported by millions of likes, retweets and favorites) on a nearly daily basis…
But how historically accurate is this quip? Can Henry Ford be believed? Should we build products without asking a single customer about their wants and needs?
After doing a little historical research I can only conclude that, while a nice one-liner, this quotation is inaccurate and we should think more carefully before relying on it.
First, Henry Ford did not invent the automobile (or even prove the market) and therefore isn’t the authority on any customer research that did occur.
The first commercial automobile was sold by Karl Benz of Germany in 1886, a decade before Ford got started. This fact is well documented and without dispute. While “primitive,” the media at the time was more than capable of percolating stories of four-wheeled horseless-carriages powered by gasoline around the industrial world.
Henry Ford already knew about Karl Benz invention (which was by then selling hundreds of models per year and on display widely in Europe) before he set about creating his own version in 1896. The only research Ford needed to do was to ask a given person on the street: “Would you buy a cheaper automobile from Karl Benz? Yes?” Market research complete!
If we are going to quote great inventors to find inspiration, we should be quoting Karl Benz (“My first customer was a lunatic. My second had a death wish.”)
Second, customers didn’t want a faster horse, they wanted a faster bicycle. Chances are if Henry Ford had asked the right customers the right questions he would have gotten the right answers.
According to historical records, Karl Benz first sought to create a motorized tricycle:”…Based on his experience with, and fondness for, bicycles, he used similar technology when he created an automobile.” [source]
In 1886, humanity was already well familiar with the two-wheeled contraption powered by chains, gears and pedals (invented in 1817). In fact, if you look closely at the first automobiles you will see those same chains, gears and wheels used in early production.
Henry Ford’s own first vehicle was even named after the bicycle: It was called the “Quadricycle” and looked suspiciously like a four-wheeled bicycle. If Ford really believed that his customers wanted a faster horse, he likely would have chosen a name more like the “autocarriage.”
Karl Benz first customer? A bicycle manufacturer named Emile Roger, probably seeking a faster bicycle and not a faster horse.
Conclusion
Henry Ford didn’t do any customer research because he didn’t need to. By the time Ford arrived, the research had already been done and the automobile market validated with demand proven. Furthermore, if Ford had asked his customers what they wanted, their answer might have been “a faster bicycle” which would certainly have been a useful insight.
While Henry Fords contributions are legendary, we shouldn’t take his advice about how to develop innovative new products.