Skip to content
Rex St. John

Get in touch

Why Decentralized Technology Threatens A “Dumb Pipe” Future For The Cloud, Rex St. John

A lot of talk is going around these days about whether or not “decentralized technology” is actually decentralized.

Originally published on the rexstjohn.com blog

Tags
  • web3

Originally published at rexstjohn.com on January 8, 2022. Recovered from the Internet Archive.

A lot of talk is going around these days about whether or not “decentralized technology” is actually decentralized. The core argument “Against” goes something like this: “Well, you still have to use all the existing hardware, data centers and infrastructure provided by the cloud, mobile phone operators and ISPs to pretend to be decentralized…so what you are doing…isn’t actually decentralized.”

I am not going to bother linking to all the articles and discussions, they are too numerous to count. I think this line of thinking has come about because the terminology and discussion have gone down the wrong road.

Let me reset the conversation and put things in their proper context:

  • The existing CAPEX that all the “centralized” providers such as ISPs and Cloud Providers is never going away and decentralized workloads will always need to run on it
  • The existing “onramps and off ramps” such as browsers, banks, mobile phones are never going away
  • Any “Volunteer” compute resources such as mobile phones, PCs, Helium Gateways will always be realistically dwarfed by the supply of enterprise grade storage, compute, connectivity infrastructure
  • Web3 and Cryptocurrencies are “Technologies of the Internet,” they do not aim to replace the internet. They are not going to build a new internet. They are going to use all the same pipes, chutes and ladders the internet uses.

So let’s talk about this correctly to understand what to expect and how to think about it.

Recently, I spoke to a startup building decentralized storage platforms on top of IPFS. Basically, you can use IPFS to “replicate” your data in multiple geographically separate locations. Why would you do this? Because the data is valuable and you don’t trust any particular cloud provider or datacenter to store that data and keep it safe.

The “Decentralization” of IFPS doesn’t come from not depending on any centralized power, it comes from the replication of the storage across an arbitrary (at least 3) number of disparate locations. Likewise, it is this same replication, lack of “lock-in” and “transportability” of that workload or storage of data which makes it “Decentralized.”

The “Real Threat” to so-called “Centralized Powers” that is posed by blockchain, web3 therefore is as follows: Web3 enables the creation of “open compute marketplaces” which provide unlimited transportability free of vendor lock-in incentivized by instant crypto payments. In this world, Cloud Service Providers risk become nothing more than “Dumb Pipes” similar to the fate of ISPs. Just because they control centralized infrastructure, it doesn’t mean they have any ability to interfere with what is occurring on their networks.

The threat will come in the form of an “Innovators Dilemma.” Web3 technologies enable the simple, instant and easy listing of compute resources on open networks and the immediate generation of payments. Over time, as the supply of such workloads and storage requests increase, cloud service providers of all types will have to choose either to take the easy money or try to build walled gardens.

Likewise, in the world of everything being an “open compute marketplace” no one will trust anyone. All workloads and storage will be replicated across multiple providers. This, in turn, will mean all available compute that isn’t nailed down must be listed to get bought and sold. If you think demand for compute is high now, you ain’t seen nothing yet. Everything must go. Everything must get used. Decentralization means massive replication and therefore geometric growth in demand.

CSPs may end up being very well compensated for choosing to go down this “dumb pipe” road.